Commonplace
  • Home
  • About Us
  • News
  • On Writing
  • Photo Albums
    • Flashback 2018
    • Flashback 2017
    • Flashbacks 2016
    • Flashbacks 2015
    • Flashbacks 2014
    • Flashbacks 2013
    • Flashbacks 2012
    • Flashbacks 2011
    • Flashbacks 2010
    • Flashbacks 2009
    • Flashbacks 2008
  • Thesis Resources
  • Archived
    • Archived Blog
  • Blog

Critique of Creekside Cafe

8/3/2011

 
Note: Hunter read this piece at the residency's Open Mic reading for students.

Summary

The noshing spot of either choice or necessity (which is unclear) for the MFA program at UAA. All you see happening is it fills up with people and then empties.  

What Works

Picture
Actual remains of a Creekside meal.
The food is, by all indication, made of actual edible matter, which is a very important characteristic for these kinds of stories. The moments right before the food is eaten are particularly interesting, in a Schroedinger’s Cat kind of way, wherein some characters perceive that the food is simultaneously edible and inedible and it is only after attempted consumption that there is any sure knowledge. 

These kinds of thought experiments generally enhance most readers’ eating experience. 
The surface tension of all available liquids is breakable, and therefore you can technically drink anything there, a world of possibility that really opens the story up. 

None of the fruit contains razor blades.

What Doesn't Work

Picture
The promise of dessert and lack of general payoff, while a kind of clever ironic twist, may alienate some readers.

The use of the metaphor “like pushing a sack of angry hammers through a rolled-up garden hose” for post-Creekside bowel movements seems forced and unnecessary.

The spoon and knife characters receive a disproportionate amount of attention. It’s like the author is constantly forgetting that the fork characters exist. 


Picture
Writers Vs. Campers
The names “Hunter” and “Robert” are used interchangeably for what appears to be the same character; furthermore, why does the author make such a point of having him spill things constantly? It is difficult to tell how old he is supposed to be.  

The salad bar character seems very flat and passive and lacks any development as the story progresses. 

The sudden introduction of the multitude of young camper characters seems unnecessary and even though they may serve some metaphorical purpose about unavoidable impediments of everyday life and herd mentality, it seems like they could possibly be reworked and combined into one character for more efficiency [1].



The dialogue between the strange intoxicated writer characters and the camper characters is forced and awkward at times. The oppressive bitterness of the writer characters seems justified only by some aversion to light and loud noises.

______________

[1] This may also help with the dessert issue. 



    This Week's Blogger: 
     Lisa Houlihan Stice    

    Thanks, Hunter!

    Archives

    January 2013
    November 2012
    September 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011

    Categories

    All
    Abject Failure
    Activities With Predetermined Outcomes
    Advice
    Alaska
    Amy O
    Awards
    Blogging
    Books
    Boooooooooooking
    Canon
    Career Choices
    Classics
    Confidence
    Contests
    Critiques
    Critiquing
    Curtis White
    Damn
    Dance
    David Foster Wallace
    David Stevenson
    Delusions Of Grandeur
    Depression
    Despair
    Dialogue
    Entertaining Readers
    Erin Hanson
    Failure
    Faith Prescott
    Field Trips
    Genre
    Grad School
    Hunter Whitworth
    Jo-Ann Mapson
    Literary Criticism
    Literature
    Mastery
    Memory
    Mentoring
    Mfa
    Mind
    Movies
    Music
    Nonfiction
    No One Reads This
    Not A Real Live Blog
    Novels
    Old Men Wrestling
    Perseverance
    Persistence
    Postmodern
    Poverty
    Practicum
    Preparation
    Publishing
    Reading
    Rejection
    Residency
    Residency Program
    Rich Chiappone
    Ron Simmons
    Sara Loewen
    Sequels To Things
    Several More Typos
    Sharks
    Submission
    Success
    Taking A Leaf From A Book Called "Paradise Lost"
    The Part Where I Pretend I'm Douglas Adams
    Thor? Who Reads This? No One? That's What I Thought.
    Time
    Tips
    Underwhelming Prequels
    Vivian Faith Prescott
    War Across Time
    Workshop
    Wrestlemania
    Writers
    Writing
    Zack Rogow

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from hillary h, Katie Loughlin, this lyre lark, wakalani, juliejordanscott, MatthewHamblen.com, Gamma Man, Nic's events, DaveReichert, HerryLawford, jemsweb, Annie Mole, jaaron, Mike Babcock, Brett Jordan, hoshi7, Jonathan Rashad, michal_hadassah, sylvrilyn, austinevan, Andrew Mason, PlasticineMonkey, *L*u*z*A*, Robert Couse-Baker, karola riegler photography, Daquella manera, blmurch, e³°°°, Alexandratx, Adam Jones, Ph.D., kalidoskopika, Brendan Adkins, h.koppdelaney, sleepyneko, Loelle, aussiegall, Howtedious, Jmiz810, ^riza^, Dawn - Pink Chick, fauxto_digit, El Bibliomata, Don Hankins, Natalia Robba, Colin_K, TAKA@P.P.R.S, Matt McGee, ElizabethHudy, cursedthing, bunnicula
  • Home
  • About Us
  • News
  • On Writing
  • Photo Albums
    • Flashback 2018
    • Flashback 2017
    • Flashbacks 2016
    • Flashbacks 2015
    • Flashbacks 2014
    • Flashbacks 2013
    • Flashbacks 2012
    • Flashbacks 2011
    • Flashbacks 2010
    • Flashbacks 2009
    • Flashbacks 2008
  • Thesis Resources
  • Archived
    • Archived Blog
  • Blog